Finding the Best Pizzelle Maker

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

If you came here looking for the best pizelle maker, chances are you already know what pizelle are!  If not, let me take a moment to introduce you to this wonderful Italian treat.

Pizelle are a very thin and crispy Italian cookie that require a special press to make, almost like a waffle iron.  Usually they are favorite with anise (think black licorice), but if that isn’t for you you can also use other flavors.

Now, let’s take a look at some electric pizelle makers.

The Best Pizelle Maker

Item
Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver
Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
Pizzelle Maker- Non-stick Electric Pizzelle Baker Press Makes Two 5-Inch Cookies at Once- Recipes...
CucinaPro Polished Pizzelle Maker
CucinaPro Mini Italian Pizzelle Waffle Maker Iron - Makes Four 3 1/4 Inch Pizzelle Traditional...
Image
Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver
Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
Pizzelle Maker- Non-stick Electric Pizzelle Baker Press Makes Two 5-Inch Cookies at Once- Recipes...
CucinaPro Polished Pizzelle Maker
CucinaPro Mini Italian Pizzelle Waffle Maker Iron - Makes Four 3 1/4 Inch Pizzelle Traditional...
Number and Size of Cookies
Two 4"
Two 5"
Two 5"
Two 5"
Four 3.25"
Price
$49.99
$69.95
$39.95
$60.48
$39.95
Item
Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver
Image
Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver
Number and Size of Cookies
Two 4"
Price
$49.99
More Info
Item
Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
Image
Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
Number and Size of Cookies
Two 5"
Price
$69.95
More Info
Item
Pizzelle Maker- Non-stick Electric Pizzelle Baker Press Makes Two 5-Inch Cookies at Once- Recipes...
Image
Pizzelle Maker- Non-stick Electric Pizzelle Baker Press Makes Two 5-Inch Cookies at Once- Recipes...
Number and Size of Cookies
Two 5"
Price
$39.95
More Info
Item
CucinaPro Polished Pizzelle Maker
Image
CucinaPro Polished Pizzelle Maker
Number and Size of Cookies
Two 5"
Price
$60.48
More Info
Item
CucinaPro Mini Italian Pizzelle Waffle Maker Iron - Makes Four 3 1/4 Inch Pizzelle Traditional...
Image
CucinaPro Mini Italian Pizzelle Waffle Maker Iron - Makes Four 3 1/4 Inch Pizzelle Traditional...
Number and Size of Cookies
Four 3.25"
Price
$39.95
More Info

All of these options are electric, because why not take advantage of modern day technology when making pizelle.

The most important think to take a look at when picking an electric pizelle maker are the size and pattern of this finished cookie.

Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press

Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver
  • Easy to use from start to finish & bakes two 4" pizzelle
  • Ready-to-bake and Ready-to-Eat indicator lights provide perfect timing
  • Nonstick baking plates remove pizzelle without breaking

Known for their kitchen electrics, Cuisinart does not disappoint with this pizelle press.  It makes two 4″ cookies, and features a knob to set your unit to the desired cooking darkness, and indicator lights for both power and to indicate if the pizelle is ready.

It also folds up for easy storage on the kitchen counter.  This is truly one of the best set it and forget it units for pizelle cooking, but don’t go too far as this thin Italian cookie cooks very fast.

Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic

Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
  • Made in USA by Palmer manufacturing
  • Makes 2 thin 5 inches cookies
  • Cast aluminum plates

This Pizelle maker looks like it is straight out of your grandmother’s kitchen in Italy.  Yes, it does plug in, but other than that is really a classic, traditional pizelle maker.

This model makes two 5″ pizelle cookies.  It lacks bells and whistles, but after heating up for about 15 minutes it is ready to crank out those pizelle.

If you are looking for a nostalgic pizelle maker, this one is it.  It makes a great gift for those looking to re-create some Italian magic.

CucinaPro Pizzelle Maker – Non Stick

Pizzelle Maker- Non-stick Electric Pizzelle Baker Press Makes Two 5-Inch Cookies at Once- Recipes...
  • Pizzelle Baker- Makes 2 pizzelles at one time- Recipes Included!
  • Pizzelle Maker- Cookies measure at 5 inches, the perfect bit size for cones
  • Pizzelle Press- Steam guard protects hands

This non-stick pizelle maker makes two 5″ cookies.  It is a modern version of a classic, but if it is a little too modern stay tuned for our next pizelle maker.

While it doesn’t look like it, it is an electric model, and has a bracket to hold the press closed as you make your pizelle.  It does not have a built in timer, but it does have an indicator light.

According to the reviews, this pizelle maker takes about 50 seconds for the perfect pizelle, but this will vary on how you like yours, and the batter you are using.

CucinaPro Pizelle Maker – Polished

CucinaPro Polished Pizzelle Maker
  • Features a built-in steam guard helps protect hands when in use
  • Power indicator light
  • Extra-thick baking plates ensure even heat distribution 7

Like its non-stick counterpart, this pizelle maker makes two 5″ cookies.  The big difference here is that this pizelle maker does not have a non-stick coating.

This model is a clear throwback to the pizelle makers your grandmother, great grandmother, and even her grandmother used.  If you are looking for a true authentic pizelle maker, with an old time feel, this is the pizelle maker for you.

CucinaPro Mini Pizelle Maker

Sale
CucinaPro Mini Italian Pizzelle Waffle Maker Iron - Makes Four 3 1/4 Inch Pizzelle Traditional...
  • Pizzelle Italian Waffle Iron - The Piccolo Pizzelle Baker makes 4 mini pizzelle cookies at once!
  • Pizzelle Maker - Non-stick baking grids ensure easy clean-up.
  • Pizzelle Iron - Features a steam guard to protect hands.

This mini Pizelle maker makes four 3.25″ pizelle.  This is great if you are making pizelle for large groups, or just looking for something different.

It operates jut like its other CucinaPro counterparts.  It is a fun option and something different than the norm when it comes to pizelle.

Picking the Best Pizelle Maker

When it comes to picking the best pizelle maker, it all comes down the size of the pizelle, and some features of the pizelle maker.

If you absolutely do not want a non-stick surface on your Pizelle maker, the Polished CucinaPro Pizelle Maker is the choice for you.  In fact, many seem to prefer this model over its non-stick counterpart.

If you are looking for the most authentic feel from a non-stick pizelle maker, then the Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic is the choice for you.

If you are looking for a 4″ pizelle, look no further than the Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press, Silver, which also has a number of advanced features like the ability to adjust darkness and cooking time.

For something a bit different, do not miss the CucinaPro Mini Pizelle Maker which makes four smaller pizelle.

Tips for Perfect Pizelles

If you do not have a family pizelle recipe, the first thing to start with is a good recipe.  I like this pizelle recipe from King Arthur Flour.  The first thing you will notice is that it uses vanilla extract instead of anise extract.

If you really want that classic Italian feel, you can also add anise extract which is probably something you don’t normally have on hand.

A pizelle maker is a lot like a waffle iron, and needs some time to break in.  In the beginning, be sure to lightly coat the plates with your favorite cooking oil.  Over time, you will probably not need to do this.

The good thing about pizelle is they are very thin, which means they cook fast, and you can make a ton in one batch.  Take your time to figure out the optimal cooking time for pizelle the way you like them.

Cleaning Your Pizelle Maker

It is important to note that the plates do not come out of the pizelle makers reviewed here.

You may automatically think that you need one with removable plates, but the truth is you can get by without them, unlike with some waffle irons.

Looking for the best waffle maker with removable plates?  Be sure to check out our guide!

To clean your pizelle maker, unplug it from the wall.  Completely soak a paper towel with water, wring it out, and place it so it covers the plates.  Then close it. You pizelle maker will make some steam, but give it a few minutes.

Remove the paper towel, and your pizelle maker will be clean!

Pizelle are a treat in every Italian household around the holidays, and the best pizelle maker is a great gift for every Italian cook.

Last update on 2019-12-06 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

0 comments… add one

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge