How to Pick the Best Broiler Pan

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

When it comes to using your oven, we all know it does a lot more than just baking.  I love to broil things in the oven, and for that I need the best broiler pan.  Broiling is completely different than baking and roasting, so for the best broiled food you really should the best broiler pan.

Best Broiler Pan

Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan
Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid
Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan
Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set, 17 inch, Silver
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch
Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75 Inch by 8.5 Inch,Black
Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black
Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan - HFA REF # 333 (50)
Stainless Steel
Steel and Non-Stick Steel
Porcelain
Porcelain
Aluminum Disposable
16.5" x 12"
11" x 7"
12.75" x 8.5"
20" x 15"
11.5" x 8.5"
$25.05
$14.59
$13.67
$32.47
$39.75
Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set
Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set, 17 inch, Silver
Stainless Steel
16.5" x 12"
$25.05
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch
Steel and Non-Stick Steel
11" x 7"
$14.59
Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan
Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75 Inch by 8.5 Inch,Black
Porcelain
12.75" x 8.5"
$13.67
Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid
Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black
Porcelain
20" x 15"
$32.47
Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan
Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan - HFA REF # 333 (50)
Aluminum Disposable
11.5" x 8.5"
$39.75

As you can see, many of these broiler pans look very similar.  A broiler pan has a slotted plate that goes over a larger pan.  This is to catch any juices from the food you are broiling, so the food stays crisp.

I often broil different types of meats, but you can broil almost anything.  Broiling is simply cooking food at a very high temperature for a short amount of time, and often very close to the heating element.  That is why allowing fat to run off with the designs of these pans is so important.

When it comes to picking the best broiler pan there are a few things to keep in mind.

First of all is the size of the pan.  If you have an idea of what you would like to cook, make sure it fits in the pan!

Next is the material of the pan.  Just like grill grates come in different materials, so do pans.  Don’t miss this guide to grill grate material to learn the basics.

Finally, is ease of cleaning.

Now, let’s take a look at some broiler pans.

Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set

Sale
Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set, 17 inch, Silver
  • Measures: 16.5" x 12" x 2" / 42cm x 30.5cm x 5cm
  • This two-piece stainless steel broiler pan with perforated top allows for grease to drain off, while you cook, for healthier results.
  • Made of stainless steel for strength and durability. Easy to clean.

When it comes to pans, I love Norpro stainless steel baking sheets.  Loving their broiler pan was not a stretch either.

Stainless steel is very, very easy to clean, and you do not need to worry about too much about cleaning it.  While yes, it does scratch, the scratches don’t do anything bad to your pan, unlike other cooking surfaces.

If you have not used a lot of stainless steel cookware before, you will notice over time it just looks sort of dirty and loses its luster.

When that time comes, simply use some Barkeeper's Friend to get it nice and shiny looking.

This stuff is the secret to cleaning stainless steel, and many other surfaces.

Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set

Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch
  • Two part pan drains fat and grease from meat and fish
  • Made of steel; non-stick for easy release and quick cleanup
  • 11 x 7 in. (27.9 x 17.8 cm)

This Wilton pan is a great broiler pan in general, with a low price point.  It has a non-stick surface for easy cleaning.

The only downside is the size of this pan, it is smaller compared to some of the others on this list.

That’s why it is important to think about what you want to broil before you purchase your pan.

Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Sale
Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75 Inch by 8.5 Inch,Black
  • COOKING DONE RIGHT: Make the perfect meals with the help of the Range Kleen BP106X 2 Piece Heavy Duty Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan. Whether it is broiling meats to perfection or baking dishes, cook with ease with this 2-piece utensil.
  • MADE FROM HIGH QUALITY MATERIALS: Heavy-duty porcelain on steel grill and base, this USA made set is safe for use for up to 1025 degrees F and has OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) quality.
  • GOOD FEATURES FOR BROILING AND BAKING: The grate of the grill allows fat drippings to drain away from meats. The Range Kleen BP106X is suitable for use on an outdoor grill and perfect for fish, meats and veggies.

This porcelain broil pan is a great model, and is a good size.

The only thing to beware of is that it is made out of porcelain, and porcelain must be cleaned gently.

However, porcelain is a great conductor of heat, so it will help your food cook very nicely and get nice and brown under the broiler.

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid

Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black
  • This product is a Factory Certified Accessory. These three words represent quality parts and accessories designed specifically for your appliance. Time tested engineering that meets our strict quality specifications
  • Package contains (1) Premium Broiler Pan and Roasting Rack
  • No tools required for installation

While this Whirlpool pan is also made out of porcelain, it is the biggest in size.  It is actually the replacement part for many Whirlpool ovens.

If you want to make a large amount of food (think burgers for a whole family and guests) at one time, this may be the broiler pan for you.

Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan

Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan - HFA REF # 333 (50)
  • Top Out Dimensions: 13" x 9-5/8"
  • Top In Dimensions: 11-1/2" x 8-1/2"
  • Bottom Dimensions: 11-1/8" x 8-1/2"

We’ve talked alot about cleaning broiler pans.  If you don’t want to bother with the cleaning aspect, these Handi-Foil broiler pans are for you.  Now, while they are disposable, they also are only one piece, so you will not get as good fat drainage from this as you would with some of the two piece sets.

As someone who uses these disposable pans probably more than they should, I have not found this to be a big deal.  Most grease is still caught by the bottom grooves in the pan, and I always remove the food as soon as I take the pan out of the oven.

Picking the Best Broiler Pan

Let’s take a look at our options one more time:

Sale
Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set, 17 inch, Silver
Measures: 16.5" x 12" x 2" / 42cm x 30.5cm x 5cm; Made of stainless steel for strength and durability. Easy to clean.
$25.05
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch
Two part pan drains fat and grease from meat and fish; Made of steel; non-stick for easy release and quick cleanup
$14.59
Sale
Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75 Inch by 8.5 Inch,Black
COOK AND CLEAN WITH EASE: The materials are easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
$13.67
Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black
Package contains (1) Premium Broiler Pan and Roasting Rack; No tools required for installation
$32.47
Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan - HFA REF # 333 (50)
Top Out Dimensions: 13" x 9-5/8"; Top In Dimensions: 11-1/2" x 8-1/2"; Bottom Dimensions: 11-1/8" x 8-1/2"
$39.75

If you really don’t want to deal with cleaning a broiler pan, the Handi-Foil Disposable broiler pan is the obvious choice.

If you don’t mind cleaning the broiler pan, and are looking for a balance in size and ease of use and cleaning, then the Norpro stainless steel broiler pan is the best choice.

Finally, if you are just looking for the best and biggest broiler pan you can get your hands on, the Whirlpool broiler pan is the one for you.

At the end of the day, all of these broiler pans will serve you well.  You just need to decide on the size and material that works best for you.

Tips for Using Your Broiler

I use my broiler quite a bit.  I currently have an electric oven with an electric broiler, but used to have a gas broiler.  I have not found much difference between the two.

When it comes to your broiler, there are often low, medium, and high settings.  You will find that you can get a little more granular and adjust the heat by placing your broiler pan on a specific rack.

For browning really greasy things, I have found that broiling on medium or high on the middle rack often results in much less grease splattering all over my oven than broiling on a higher rack.

If you want to just brown something, you may want to put it on higher rack on a higher setting, for a shorter amount of time.

If you are trying to cook something thoroughly, like a piece of meat, you will have better luck in the middle rack or on a higher rack setting with a lower temperature.

You will also want to flip your meat half way through cooking so that both sides are evenly browned.  When you use the best broiler pan, all of the grease will sink to the bottom of the pan, and your food won’t sit in it.

Last update on 2020-07-07 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

1 comment… add one

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge